MLB Home Run Props, Picks & Odds Today for 4-19: Bashing Butler!

Today's MLB slate offers a number of home run prop bets, and our expert MLB predictions have found three that could go yard today, including the Athletics' Lawrence Butler.

Kenny Ducey - Betting Analyst at Covers
Kenny Ducey • Betting Analyst
Apr 19, 2025 • 11:54 ET • 4 min read
Lawrence Butler of the Athletics
Photo By - Imagn Images.

Saturday is always a glorious day to bet on baseball, and this one should be no different with plenty of struggling arms making their way to the hill to step up against some menacing power threats.

We’ll take a look at three home-run threats who are beginning to heat up and should find the seats as they begin their march up the league leaderboard.

Here are my free MLB player props for Saturday, April 19.

Best MLB home run props today

HR picks for April 19

Jonathan Aranda (+420 at FanDuel)

I’m looking to fade New York Yankees starter Carlos Carrasco here. He’s pitched to a decent amount of contact in the air over his career, but this season—with a Yankees team that loves to convert its hurlers into fly-ball arms—he’s operating over 10 points higher than average in the fly ball department.

His slider has been torched for two homers and a .933 xSLG in four appearances, and that should open the door for Jonathan Aranda, hitting a blistering .382 to begin the year, to go deep.

It’s early, but Aranda has clearly taken a liking to sliders from righties – going deep once and posting a 1.776 xSLG in a limited sample. He certainly won’t keep that up all season long, but that’s more than enough reason to believe in the slugger here.

We should see plenty of fly balls in a park that grades out top-10 in park factor for homers so far this season.

Marcell Ozuna (+360 at FanDuel)

The ever-mediocre Simeon Woods-Richardson will be pitching to an Atlanta Braves offense that finally found some life at the plate on Friday night. While the odds aren’t the spiciest on many of these Braves hitters, there should be a number of homers, and the Big Bear is my first target.

Marcell Ozuna may be off to a slow start in the home run department, but two of his three have come in the last five games, and now he’ll face an extreme fly-ball pitcher at home, who’s been known to throw strikes and enters the day with a dastardly .579 Expected Slugging Percentage.

Ozuna has destroyed changeups from righties with a .686 xSLG since the start of last season and has 13 home runs in total against changeups and fastballs. The change was the pitch which yielded the most homers for Woods-Richardson a year ago, and so far this season, it’s come home with a .667 xSLG in a limited sample.

He should see plenty of both, and against a less-menacing strikeout arm, should get us on the board.

Lawrence Butler (+450 at DraftKings)

The last piece of the puzzle is Lawrence Butler, a player who’s been trying to rediscover his power stroke and lift the ball a bit more.

He’s started to figure things out, hitting a home run on Thursday, and now he’ll face an inexperienced arm in Chad Patrick who has been a heavy fly-ball pitcher throughout his career in the minor leagues and has been the same guy in a limited number of big-league innings.

He should help Butler lift the ball and tap into his power, and that’s bared plenty of fruit with Butler hitting .273 against fly-ball pitchers so far this season. He’s also crushed cut-fastballs with an .812 xSLG  since the start of last season, and that’s the pitch which Patrick is currently relying upon the most.

  1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Blue Jays (+600)
  2. Aaron Judge Yankees (+160)
  3. Kyle Manzardo Guardians (+550)

Betting info courtesy of DraftKings

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Kenny Ducey - Covers
Betting Analyst

Kenny Ducey has worked in sports media for more than 10 years and began his journey as a credentialed reporter with Fordham University's WFUV Sports before moving on to Sports Illustrated. There, he wrote about baseball, basketball, and tennis - twice covering the NBA Finals.

He's been in the betting space for seven years, and has established himself as a top expert in MLB and tennis handicapping with brands like Tennis Channel, NBC Sports, and DraftKings. He's also been a frequent guest on betting shows such as MLB's Bettor's Eye and Tennis Bets Live.

Kenny has a knack for identifying underappreciated pitchers and tennis players as moneyline underdogs and credits his unique data analysis and hours of watching sports as the biggest reasons for success through the years. His best advice to bettors? Watch the games, trust your eye, and always question the public narrative.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo